There are times when someone sits down to watch a film and after 90 minutes realize that they've been sitting there in stunned silence the entire time. Did they like it? Maybe, maybe not. Was it a good movie? Well, it was certainly a "good for you" movie. But was it fun, was it enjoyable? It was both technically impressive and entirely engrossing, but enjoyable, who knows. Perhaps, just perhaps, the person you're talking to just finished watching Waltz with Bashir. This 2008 release, which won a DGA award for Best Documentary, a Golden Globe for Best Foreign Language Film, and was nominated for an Academy Award in the same category is certainly an experience.
When I was in graduate school, I had a professor – a documentary professor – who had an incredibly broad definition of what makes for a documentary film. Waltz with Bashir unquestionably would fit my documentary professor's amorph
ous, widely encompassing definition, but it might not fit the standard definition. The film, written and directed by Ari Folman, is an animated one.
The main character in it is Ari, and his character spends the majority of the film remembering and interviewing people about Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon (the First Lebanon War). Within the context of the film, Ari is trying to remember what part he played – if any – in a massacre, and to that end, he is interviewing other people with whom he spent time during the war and/or folks who may be able to shed light on what happened. The film, consequently, is loaded with flashbacks and functions much more as a series of short stories rather than a single story.
As for the truth behind it, and what makes this a documentary, all tales told by veterans in the film are true, or, at the very least, true for the people who told them (one of the themes the movie deals with is the vicissitudes of memory). The vast majority of the real people who are turned into animated characters for the film are in fact the people to whom the stories happened (only two actors were used). However, while the film strings the stories together into a single overarching plot, that part isn't necessarily true, Ari didn't go out and find friends from the war and link up with other people through them, he
put up an advertisement looking for stories from the war.
Is that relevant? I don't know; that probably depends on your definition of "truth." The stories from the war actually took place, they just don't necessarily go together, and don't necessarily fit with Ari's life in such a neat, pat, manner. Plus, as I indicated above, the film is animated, which, for some, may hurt its truth claim.
As for the animation, it's absolutely brilliant and completely unique. It may look a little like rotoscoping, but in one of the behind the scenes featurettes, an animator is quite clear about the fact that it isn't, everything in the film (save the last few live actions shots) is in fact fully animated. Several of the featurettes deal with the construction of the film and the animation (there is also a Q&A with Ari Folman). The entire piece was actually filmed first and then edited. Storyboards were made from that, those were then roughly animated, and then the final film's animation was done on computer using the rough animatics as a guide. The final result is a completely different visual look for the piece, one that is cartoony and stylized, but real in an oddly disturbing way.
Sadly, the Blu-ray release of the film doesn't do the actual animation any favors, as the many night scenes appear terribly grainy. Additionally, the live action footage at the end of the film was clearly not shot in high definition (it is too old for that), and doesn't look particularly good when upconverted. Both the Hebrew and English audio tracks for the main feature are far better than the video. The sound is crisp and clear and even some of the more difficult accents completely intelligible.
Waltz with Bashir represents not just a brilliant achievement in terms of animation, but it tells a fascinating story – set of stories – about war and responsibility and action and inaction. It is an examination of a what people do during war, what they forget, and where war leaves the survivors. It is a powerful and wonderfully interesting film.
Is it true? Is it documentary?
There's truth in it certainly, there's documentary in it. Does the rest matter?
ence classes -- he is not only hysterically funny, but he helps the average person approach science in a wholly accessible and interesting way. I may question is choice of vests, but even those show that he is simply having fun, and making science fun. Really, it is the entire production team that deserves credit for making what could otherwise be rather dry incredibly enjoyable.
e Russian and U.S. Special Forces capture the leader of Kazakhstan, Ivan Radek, a general who has caused genocide and sponsored terrorism. Korshunov's plan is presented to the audience as a simple one – hijack Air Force One with some help from the inside and make the U.S. convince Russia to let Radek go.
Vice President, Kathryn Burnett (Glenn Close) find themselves arguing over who is in charge – they even call in the Attorney General (Philip Baker Hall), asking him to bring a copy of the Constitution with him – and the best course of action. The fight does not hamper their performance during the crisis, but is absolutely believable.
First up, on June 8 at 9pm, the fifth season of The Closer will begin. The show, featuring Kyra Sedgwick as Deputy Police Chief Brenda Leigh Johnson, has been one of the shows that TNT has built its brand around in recent years. Sedgwick has been nominated for multiple awards for the series and brought home a Golden Globe in 2007.
TNT's next premiere night is June 16, and on that night the network will deliver two new shows and one returning series: Wedding Day, Hawthorne, and Saving Grace. Taking the last -- and the show that airs at 10pm -- first, Holly Hunter is back as the troubled-but-great-at-her-job police detective Grace Hanadarko. She doesn't quite see dead people, but she does regularly get messages and advice from her "last-chance angel," Earl. The series, not quite as decorated as The Closer, has still earned Hunter two Screen Actors Guild nominations. While Saving Grace has never quite been my cup of tea, it does have the hallmarks of a well-produced, potentially interesting series and asks questions of itself and the audience.
a nursing administrator's perspective on a hospital isn't wholly outside the box, but it's not something routine on television, and Smith is certainly good in it.